Ceres, a nonprofit advocacy organization, submitted a public comment letter urging the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to withdraw its proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8, the principal mechanism for shareholders to include proposals in company proxy ballots. The letter argues that repeal would weaken investors’ influence over corporate decisions and remove a mechanism for identifying financial risks and improving governance.
To support its case, Ceres points to shareholder proposals seeking disclosure of sustainability risks and changes to board elections. By 2025, 94% of S&P 500 companies issued sustainability reports. The proportion with annual elections for all directors rose from roughly 40% in 1999 to 88% in 2025. Ceres presents these developments as evidence of shareholder proposals’ contribution to corporate disclosure and governance practices.
The letter warns that rescission could make submitting proposals difficult or impossible for retail and small shareholders, increase litigation over proxy content and push investors toward “vote no” campaigns or proxy fights. It also argues that the SEC’s economic analysis overlooks asset managers and pension funds holding trillions of dollars that rely on voting on proposals, even when they do not submit them. Ceres challenges both the SEC’s position that it lacks authority to issue the rule and its argument that shareholder proposals impose costly, unnecessary burdens on public companies.