The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) published remarks arguing for a shift away from its conflict minerals disclosure framework, identifying legislative repeal and a statutory national security waiver as possible options. The speech contends that the requirements have failed to improve security in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), harmed mining livelihoods and discouraged U.S. sourcing of critical minerals. Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act remains a statutory mandate.
The framework requires companies to disclose whether conflict minerals in their products originated in the DRC or adjoining countries. The remarks cite findings from the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) that an estimated 62% of companies performing due diligence still could not determine whether their minerals came from the region. The GAO also found that peace and security had not improved and associated the rule with a spread of violence, particularly around gold mines. The speech argues that companies’ withdrawal from regional sourcing reduced miners’ incomes without cutting off armed groups’ revenues, while allowing Chinese buyers to gain ground.
The remarks place those concerns against an unresolved legal backdrop: A 2015 court ruling found portions of the implementing rule unconstitutional, and the matter was remanded to the SEC in 2017. The speech argues that securities disclosures should focus on financially material information for investors, with diplomacy, development and economic policy addressing conflict and critical mineral supply needs.