The Bank of England has published a staff working paper suggesting that falling vacancy posting costs explain a substantial share of the long-term rise in UK vacancies. Cheaper recruitment advertising has raised the estimated equilibrium level of vacancies, meaning comparisons of the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio with historical averages may misrepresent labour market slack and the associated signals for wage and inflation pressures.
Using recruitment advertising data from 1982 onward, the paper finds that real advertising expenditure per vacancy has fallen by more than 80% since 2000 as recruitment shifted from print to online platforms. Lower costs increase firms’ willingness to create and maintain vacancies without necessarily implying a corresponding increase in underlying labour demand. The expenditure measure serves as a proxy for vacancy posting costs rather than a comprehensive estimate of recruitment expenses.
Estimates incorporating posting costs and labour productivity indicate that equilibrium labour market tightness has increased materially over the past four decades. By contrast, the surge in tightness following the pandemic appears to have reflected vacancies rising above equilibrium. The subsequent decline has brought the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio below its estimated equilibrium, suggesting some spare capacity. That assessment remains uncertain, particularly because changes in labour supply or equilibrium unemployment could alter the benchmark.