The Federal Reserve Board published a research paper assessing whether households substitute consumption intertemporally when real interest rates move, finding no evidence that they systematically shift the timing of consumption in response to interest rate changes. The paper combines microdata on the intertemporal marginal propensity to consume with 10 structural macroeconomic shocks. While several of the shocks generate large and persistent changes in real interest rates that would imply sizable intertemporal substitution in many models, the results indicate that changes in the expected path of income explain almost all of the aggregate consumption response, leaving no role for intertemporal substitution.